Best Substitutes for Strained Tomatoes

5 Best Substitutes for Strained Tomatoes

Strained tomatoes, known for their smooth and concentrated texture, are a popular kitchen staple used in various dishes, including soups, stews, sauces, and casseroles. However, there are situations where you might run out of strained tomatoes or simply want to explore different flavors.

Thankfully, there are numerous substitutes that can match the qualities of strained tomatoes while adding a unique twist to your culinary creations.

In this article, we will explore the five best substitutes for strained tomatoes and provide some frequently asked questions to help you make informed decisions in your cooking adventures.

What is the Best Substitute for Strained Tomatoes

1. Tomato Passata

tomato puree

Tomato passata, often referred to as tomato puree, is an excellent substitute for strained tomatoes. It shares a similar texture and flavor profile, making it an ideal replacement in recipes.

Tomato passata is made from pureed, cooked tomatoes that are strained to remove seeds and skin, resulting in a smooth, thick liquid. It maintains the essence of fresh tomatoes while providing a vibrant red color to your dishes.

It works great in pasta sauces, soups, and other dishes where a smooth consistency is desired. When using it as a substitute for strained tomatoes, consider adjusting the seasoning and acidity levels to suit your taste preferences.

2. Tomato Sauce

tomato sauce

Tomato sauce is another readily available and convenient substitute for strained tomatoes. Unlike tomato passata, tomato sauce usually contains additional ingredients such as herbs, spices, garlic, and onions. It offers a richer and more complex flavor, which can add depth to your dishes.

When using tomato sauce as a substitute, you may need to dilute it slightly with water to achieve the desired consistency of strained tomatoes.

Additionally, be mindful of the seasoning in the original recipe, as tomato sauce may already contain salt and other spices.

3. Crushed Tomatoes

crushed tomatoes

Crushed tomatoes are coarsely chopped and packed in tomato juice, making them a good alternative to strained tomatoes. While they might have a slightly chunkier texture, they retain the fresh taste of tomatoes and work well in recipes that benefit from a more rustic feel.

When substituting crushed tomatoes for strained tomatoes, consider blending or processing the crushed tomatoes for a smoother consistency.

Additionally, take into account the liquid content in the original recipe, as crushed tomatoes may release more liquid during cooking.

4. Tomato Puree

tomato passata

Tomato puree is made by cooking tomatoes until they break down into a smooth paste, and it can serve as a viable substitute for strained tomatoes. This option offers a concentrated tomato flavor and a thicker consistency, making it a suitable replacement in various recipes.

To use tomato puree as a substitute, consider diluting it with water or broth to achieve a texture closer to strained tomatoes.

Also, be aware of the sweetness of tomato puree, as it can differ from strained tomatoes, and adjust the seasonings accordingly.

5. Homemade Fresh Tomato Puree

homemade tomato puree

For those who prefer a more hands-on approach, creating your own fresh tomato puree can be an excellent alternative to strained tomatoes.

Simply blanch ripe tomatoes in boiling water for a minute or two, then plunge them into ice water. This process allows you to easily remove the skin and seeds. Afterward, blend the tomatoes until smooth, and you’ll have a fresh and vibrant tomato puree that perfectly emulates the qualities of strained tomatoes.

When using homemade fresh tomato puree, you have the advantage of controlling the level of seasoning and acidity to tailor it precisely to your tastes.

Keep in mind that the flavor might vary based on the type of tomatoes used, so consider experimenting with different varieties to find your favorite blend.

Also read best substitutes for bleu cheese and substitutes for milk in mashed potatoes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use tomato paste as a substitute for strained tomatoes?

While tomato paste shares a similar thick consistency to strained tomatoes, it is highly concentrated and intense in flavor. It is best to dilute tomato paste with water or broth before using it as a substitute.

Are there any non-tomato substitutes for strained tomatoes?

Yes, if you are looking for tomato-free alternatives, you can use pureed red bell peppers or carrots as a substitute for strained tomatoes. Both options provide a similar texture and natural sweetness, allowing you to create unique flavors in your dishes.

Is tomato puree the same as strained tomatoes?

No, Tomato puree and strained tomatoes are not the same. Tomato puree is made with tomato paste and water, and the tomatoes are strained with salt and citric acid. On the other hand, strained tomatoes are made with gently cooked, ripe tomatoes that are strained to remove seeds and skin.


Strained tomatoes are undeniably a versatile ingredient that adds depth and richness to countless recipes. However, running out of this pantry staple or wanting to experiment with different flavors shouldn’t hinder your culinary creativity.

The five substitutes we explored – tomato passata, tomato sauce, crushed tomatoes, tomato puree, and homemade fresh tomato puree – each offer their unique characteristics to suit various dishes.

Remember to adjust the seasoning, consistency, and acidity when substituting strained tomatoes to ensure your dish retains its deliciousness. Moreover, don’t be afraid to explore non-tomato alternatives for an exciting twist to your recipes.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *